A24's Elizabeth Holmes documentary You Can See Everything and DC's Clayface finished the Halloween weekend nearly level at about $10.5 million apiece, one of the slowest weekends of the year, according to Variety. Final numbers Monday.
The mechanism is the math, and the math is not on the cape's side. Clayface, a $44 million R-rated origin story about a Batman villain, is in its second weekend with $83 million worldwide, a modest win in studio language, which is what they call it when the spreadsheet is a shrug. Staring it down is a three-hour documentary about a jailed tech fraudster that A24 made for $7 million, has already grossed $63.88 million domestically, and has not even opened internationally yet.
The Stare Down is three weekends old now. Two films, each around $10.5 million, on the weekend families chose candy over tickets. One is a comic book guy made of clay, the other is the woman who sold billions in lies. Same gross. That is not a tie. That is a verdict.
The fun part is the multiple. The doc has already made its entire budget back ten times over. The clay guy is still doing the walk of shame. The industry spent nine figures on the cape, the truth spent seven, and the audience split the difference and then quietly leaned honest. Hollywood's whole problem in one weekend: it cannot tell spectacle from a woman being truthful, and the receipts say the honest one sold more.
YOUR TURN: Is the Holmes doc winning the weekend, or has the industry been losing to the truth for three straight weekends?
Comments (1)