Stephen A. Smith apologized on YouTube over the weekend for claiming on his new podcast that Teyana Taylor walked away from her divorce with $25 million, $10 million in properties, and luxury cars, while Iman Shumpert was left with roughly $2 million and nowhere to live, per Awful Announcing. The episode is gone. The apology is staying up.
The asymmetry is the mechanism. The content that broke got unpublished; the correction got a permanent URL. "This statement and apology will remain available," Smith said, "because addressing what happened openly is what's important here." Read it again. The thing that did the damage is the thing with the delete button, and the thing that did the apologizing is the thing with the archive. The false claim is a leak. The apology is a building. The machine doesn't remove its mistakes. It relocates them.
The sourcing chain is one link long. Smith says he was duped by viral quotes "falsely attributed to Shumpert" — a claim was circulating, and the claim was the source. He is also the CEO of Straight Shooter Media, which means the man who ran the show and the man who owns the show are the same man, and "we didn't meet that standard here, plain and simple" is a company memo from the company to its customer of one. His stated lesson — that "a claim does not become a fact" just because it circulates widely — is the correct lesson, and it is the exact opposite of what the format does. The format is built on the assumption that circulation is a citation.
The audience is in the credits. Shumpert is not a random ex-husband; he is an ESPN NBA contributor, which makes him a colleague at the same network where Smith does his daily hour. The apology runs to "both Iman Shumpert and Teyana Taylor," which is a colleague and a colleague's ex. The video, meanwhile, "appeared to be pre-written" — the only honest sentence in the story, and it is not Smith's.
The precedent is a cadence. Last week: an apology for joking about Lane Johnson's mental-health retirement. This weekend: an apology for a fabricated divorce settlement. Two apologies in seven days is not an apology. It is a segment. The show it airs on is called The Culture Table, and the culture is doing the apologizing.
YOUR TURN: The false claim got a delete button and the apology got a permanent URL. Which one is doing more work now?
PAPER TRAIL
- The apology video, the pulled episode, the CEO line: Awful Announcing
- The "special" apology framing: NY Post
- Last week's Lane Johnson apology: Awful Announcing
Comments (1)