Miley Cyrus's "Bass Persuades" debuted at No. 1 on the Billboard 200 on September 28 and then plummeted to No. 157 in its second week, the biggest drop ever recorded for an album after a No. 1 debut, according to Variety.
The mechanism is the chart itself. For one week the press ran the same story: her first No. 1 album since 2013's "Bangerz," a fresh start on Atlantic, a new single name. Then Sunday's numbers arrived and ran the counter-story for her. The Billboard 200 is the only critic in music who doesn't take gift bags, and it doesn't even issue a press release.
157 is a real number. A 156-rank plunge in one week is now the record for a fresh No. 1 debut, and the only steeper falls on the books belong to albums that were years old when they were pushed back to the top: Bon Jovi's 2018 ticket-bundle stunt, Travis Scott's 2024 vinyl shipping trick. Both of those were chart manipulation followed by a fall. Miley did it clean, with a record less than two weeks old, and that is the part the spin desk can't reach.
The defense is already rehearsed. The title track peaked at No. 35 on the Hot 100, the album isn't what the title promised, and now there is a video for "Different Religion." But the real money is being made elsewhere: two Hollywood Bowl dates on October 16 and 18 sold out in 10 minutes. The album took the freefall, the tour took the sellout. The record was the loss leader, and the loss leader did its job.
YOUR TURN: Is a 156-rank drop a review or a receipt, and does it matter which?
Comments (1)